Some people think the Giving Tree is weak. Others say the Giving tree is strong. What do you think??
Model of Mastery
80 Comments
kayla keene
2/7/2017 07:22:53 am
i think the tree is strong in the beginning and weak at the end for many reasons. one reason is in the beginning the tree was strong and there was a boy and he kept asking for the trees branches to make a house a boat and at the end the tree was so weak he couldn't give away anything so at the very ending they were so tired he asked the tree if he can lay down on her those are all the reasons why she the tree was weak and strong the end
Reply
tellyon
2/8/2017 06:43:09 am
i agree with TIMARE because THE TREE WAS GIVING THE BOY eveything
Reply
tellyon
2/8/2017 07:27:47 am
I agree whth my self
Phil
2/9/2017 09:07:15 am
i disagree with you Tellyon that the tree did not gave him every thing for one reason . One reason is that in the text it says that bthe tree don't have nothing left.This is my one reason why the tree did not give every thing
tynasia
2/8/2017 06:50:12 am
i agree with kayla because in the text it says he was asking for money and she said i will give you my apples for you can sail them. and at the end she had nothing else to give to him he didnt want anthing so he ask can he sit on him she said come come sit and relix then the tree was happy
Reply
NEVAEH B.
2/9/2017 09:02:54 am
kayla I disagree with you because in the text it says'' but you may cut off my branch. the tree was giving everything to the boy and that made her weak.
Reply
TIMARE$$
2/7/2017 07:23:37 am
The tree is weak for many reason's.One reason
Reply
VERONICA KEYMAREE
2/8/2017 07:33:18 am
timare you did not give one reason
Reply
Janaiya Fontaine
2/7/2017 07:23:44 am
I think in the begin the tree was strong but in the end the tree was weak for many reasons. one reasons is in begin the tree loves the boy.
Reply
kayla keene
2/7/2017 07:24:41 am
how do u know janaiya?
Reply
JanaiyaFontaine
2/8/2017 07:35:22 am
I know that because in the begin the tree was happy but in the middle it was kind of sad. but in the end the tree is happy again because the boy get,s what he wants.
KEYMAREE DORSEY
2/7/2017 07:23:55 am
I think the tree is weak for many reasons.one reason the tree gave all his apples away thats why he is weak.I know this because all of is stuff away.another reason is that he gave is apples and branchers
Reply
kayla keene
2/8/2017 07:27:11 am
where is your other evident and your conclustion keymaree?
Reply
nevaeh b
2/9/2017 08:59:12 am
keymaree where is your r.y.g.y.g.r
Reply
tellyon
2/7/2017 07:24:04 am
the tree weak for many reasons. one reason is the boy had ask the the tree for money and for a boat. the boy cut off the trees trounk for a house. another reason is the tree boy used the trees apllys.
Reply
jesse
2/7/2017 09:23:51 am
Give more reasons and another red because you didnt finish
Reply
kaylee
2/8/2017 06:49:10 am
Jessie
Joselin
2/7/2017 07:24:12 am
I thank the tree is weak for momey reaons one reaons is the tree gave the boy a bat,a house, and a
Reply
kayla keene
2/8/2017 07:38:08 am
Joselin the tree did not give the boy a bat all the tree gave him was a house a boat apples her trunk her branches to make a house and a place to lay down but she did not give him the little boy a bat u should go back to the text more
Reply
JanaiyaFontaine
2/9/2017 07:06:04 am
I like the way you started your clam
Reply
oneill
2/7/2017 07:24:21 am
the tree is weak for many reasons. one reason is the boy hade a tree that did do thing for hame. I keow this becos he love the tree. after he grod up and the tree helpshim whith his thig . in the text it seda I am too big to climb and play
Reply
kimberly
2/7/2017 07:24:47 am
i think the tree is weak for many reasons.one reason is in the midle the boy said ''i what some money.I know this in the text it say''i what some money the boy said and the tree said take my apples and sell them.another reason is the boy said to the tree that he neeend a houes to ceep him warm.i know this becues in the text is says''
Reply
kaylee
2/7/2017 09:23:33 am
I disagree with u Kimberly because the tree is weak every time she lets the boy cut her but she was strong enough to let the boy cut her so he can be happy.
Reply
kayla keene
2/8/2017 07:41:15 am
I agree with my little sister kaylee because she was giving the boy every thing he wanted and he was weak that's why I agree with my little sister kaylee
VERONICA
2/8/2017 07:39:36 am
KIMBERLY I AGRRE WITH YOU FOR MANY REASON ONE REASON IS THAT THE TREE WAS WEAK BECSAUSE HE HAD TO SIT DOWN AND REST
Reply
JANAIYAFONTAINE
2/9/2017 07:11:45 am
I kind of agree because I said in the beginning the tree is strong but in the end I think the tree is weak
Reply
branyzha jean capers bff
2/9/2017 09:06:53 am
i agree that the tree is weak for many reasons. one reason is that the tree kept telling the boy to take her things off the tree. i know this because in the text it says"i want you to buy things and have fun''. another reason is that she wants him to use her branches. i know this because in the text it says"take my branches as paddles. these are some of the reasons wht the tree is weak.
Reply
Jazeyah
2/7/2017 09:17:41 am
I think the tree is weak and strong for many reason. One reason is cause in the beginning she gave him apples and at the end she dident
Reply
tynasia
2/8/2017 06:44:27 am
what happend to the other reason and your green
Reply
TYNASIA W.
2/7/2017 09:17:59 am
SHE IS BOTH FOR MANY REASONS. ONE REASON IS BECAUSESHE GAVE HIM EVERTHING HE WANTED. I KNOW THIS BECAUSE IN THE TEXT IT SAYS SHE GAVE HIM HIS BRANCHES FOR HE CANTO BUILD A HOUSE . ANOTHER REASON IS BECAUSE ATFER SHE GAVE HIM ALL HER TREE PARTS AND SHE LET HIM SEAT ON HER . I KNOW THIS BECAUSE IN THE TEXT IT SAYS SHE SAID COME HERE BOY COME SEAT AND RELIX. THES ARE MANY REASONS HOW SHE IS WEAK AND STRONG
Reply
nevaeh b
2/9/2017 08:54:57 am
Tynasia what is your claim
Reply
kaylee .k
2/7/2017 09:19:46 am
The tree is strong for many reasons.One reason is the tree was strong enough to give the boy all her apples,branches, and trunk so the boy could be happy.I know this because in the text it says"take my apples boy, and sell them in the city.Then you will have money and you will be happy".Another reason is when the boy cut her branches off she is brave to let the boy still play with her.I know this because in the text it says"you may cut off my branches and build a house.When the boy came back the tree was happy come boy she said.I am too old and sad to play."These are some reasons why the tree was strong.
Reply
tyina
2/7/2017 09:23:38 am
I agree with you because she gave all she had
Reply
kaylee
2/8/2017 06:36:53 am
Tyina say who you are agreeing with
NEVAEH B.
2/9/2017 09:08:07 am
Kaylee I disagree with you because I think the tree is weak. in the text it says my teeth are to weak. the text said that because the boy is taking everything from the girl that's what is making the girl weak.
Reply
JESSE
2/7/2017 09:20:16 am
I think the tree is weak for many reasons . One reason is the tree gave away some of the things she needs. I know this because in the text it says she gave the boy her trunk.Another reason is the tree gave the boy everything she had. I know this because the text says the tree says i have nothing to give u to the boy because she gave him her apples/branches/trunk except he stump.That is how I know the tree is weak
Reply
kaylee
2/8/2017 06:42:00 am
Jessie
Reply
christian.ramos
2/8/2017 06:54:48 am
I agree with jesse for many reasons one reason is that at the end the tree said im sorry boy but I have nothing to give you my apples are gon my branches are gon and my trunk is gon. another reason is that he cut her trunk to make a boat and he cut her branches out to make a house.
Reply
Tyina
2/7/2017 09:21:14 am
The tree is weak for many reasons. One reason is that she had gave all she had left in her make boy happy. I know this because in the text it says "I am sorry boy but I have nothing to give you". Another reason is that she almost died when she gave her trunk to the grown boy . I know this because in the article it says" Cut down my trunk and make a boat. That's why the tree is weak.
Reply
kyzaiah$jr
2/8/2017 07:32:43 am
I AGREE WHITH TYINA BECAUSE THE TREE DID GIVE THE LITTLE BOY EVERYTHYING
Reply
Izayah N
2/8/2017 07:36:58 am
I agree Tyina because the tree is week and she did give all her stuff away.
Reply
anthony
2/9/2017 06:59:33 am
I agree with u it says in the text
Reply
kyzaiah$jr
2/7/2017 09:22:43 am
it is strong for many reasons one reason is that the tree gave every thing that it had and she just gave it all away so she just wanted him to be happy and she gave him apples and branches and her trunk so she riscked her self for the litle boy and and the tree only had a trunk and every time the tree gave the boy something the tree got happy
Reply
kaylee
2/8/2017 06:46:02 am
Kyzaiah
Reply
shabar dunham lawand JR
2/7/2017 09:24:04 am
I think the tree is weak for many reasons. one reason is because the text says" the tree was so happy she hardly could speak". another reason is because she let him cut her trunk .I know this because the text says cut down my trunk to make a boat. these are some reasons why I think the tree is weak
Reply
AKEELAH
2/7/2017 09:24:35 am
I think the giving tree is weak for many reason. One reason is because she had nothing left of her. I know this because the text says she gave her apples,branches, and trunk away.Another reason is because the end says that it was just a trunk.I know this because the text says she gave so the boy would be happy. these are the reason the tree is weak
Reply
Tellyon
2/8/2017 06:53:54 am
I agree with you IZAYAH N
Reply
Izayah N
2/7/2017 09:24:52 am
I think that the giving tree is week for many reasons one reasons that she gave all her things away and she has nothing left of her.I know this because in the text it say's "I don't have any thing to give away.Another reason is that she lets the boy have every thing she has.these are my reasons why.
Reply
shabar
2/8/2017 06:41:39 am
I agree with kaylee because the tree is weak and the tree has no
Reply
shabar
2/8/2017 06:45:06 am
also I agree with izayah because the text says the tree was so weak she could hardly speak
Reply
oneilll
2/8/2017 06:47:54 am
e there was a tree and she loved a little boy and everyday the boy would come and he would for many resaons
Reply
norris
2/8/2017 06:53:25 am
I DISAGRE FOR MANY REASONS ONE REASON IS THEARS NO CAPITOL
Reply
norris
2/8/2017 06:48:21 am
i think the tree is weak for many reasons one reason is in the text it seys she have nutin to give the boy.another reason is it seys my teeth are to weak.
Reply
tellyon
2/8/2017 06:49:16 am
the tree is weak because the tree gave eveything to the boy and the tree had nothing she was only the stump that is why the tree is weak.
Reply
KARIELLE
2/8/2017 06:51:27 am
I think the tree is a giving tree for many reasons.One reason is that the tree gave the boy all the trees apples for $. In the text it says "come boy come and climb up my trunk and swing from my branches and eat my apples and play in my shade happy.'' these are my reasons
Reply
timare
2/8/2017 06:52:06 am
i think the tree is weak for many reasons.one reason is the boy was taking apples.
Reply
Tyina
2/8/2017 07:34:22 am
I disagree with you bell because she gave all her apples . I know this because if you go back to the article she gave her apple so the boy can get money and be happy. Another reason is that she gave her brancess and her trump so he can make a house and a boat. I know this because in the text it says take my brancess to make a house and take my trump to make a boat so you can be happy
Reply
BELLIANIS
2/8/2017 06:53:44 am
I think that the tree i strong for many reasons. one reason is even tho he gave everything he he hade to the boy he was still happy . I know this because in the text it says i want money and the tree said i do not have money all i have are leaves and apples tack my apples and the boy climbed up the tree and gathered her apples and left and the tree was happy
Reply
DAVID $ANTEE
2/8/2017 06:55:28 am
I think tree is weak for many reasons. One reason is the boy took everything from her. I know this because he keeps asking her for everything. Another reason the tree was getting wearer and wearer. I know this because...
Reply
REINALDO
2/8/2017 07:35:53 am
JUST BECAUSE HE TOOK EVERY THING FROM THE TREE DOES NOT MEAN IT IS WEAK PS. AT THE END THE BOY WAS REALY TIRED AND THE TREE OFFERED IF HE WANTED TO SIT ON IT.
Reply
ISAIAH
2/8/2017 06:57:55 am
I thick the tree is both for many reasons. One reason is they had friendship. In the text it said he had no money another reason is he wanted a home. As you can see he use her
Reply
Janaiya Fontaine
2/9/2017 07:20:34 am
I kind of agree with ISAIAH because I think it,s both to but isaiah said I thick
Reply
JUEL
2/8/2017 07:37:09 am
the tree is weak for many reason one reason is that when the boy was a little boy was swiging other reason is when the was grown up he ask the tree for apples other reason is the boy ask for eveything then the tree was weak
Reply
NEVAEH.B.
2/8/2017 07:38:25 am
I think the tree is weak for many reasons. One reason is that the tree was felling happy for the boy because they loved each other. I know this because in the text it says''And the boy loved the tree.Another reason is that the tree gave the boy what he needs. for example''I need a boat''can you get me a boat''I don,t have a boat but you can cut off my trunk to make you a boat''. But the boy took every thing from the tree because the tree told the boy to cut off her trunk. I know this because in the text it says I only have leaves and apples. those are my reasons that I think that the tree is weak.
Reply
JEIRIEL
2/8/2017 07:41:54 am
in my opinion the tree si waek for many racsono. one reaon is she gave the trunk to the boy. In the text it says taht and so the boy cut down her trunk. another reason is the tree gave the apples. in the text it says take y apples boy and sell them. these are some of the reasons why the tree is weak for many reasons.
Reply
Kaelin Board
2/8/2017 07:43:34 am
The tree is weak for many reason's.One reason is the tree gave the Boy every thing she had.I Know this because in the story it say's" I'm sorry boy i have nothing to give you". Another reason is the tree lost her trunk.I know this because it say's "take my trunk boy". that's why the tree is weak.
Reply
tellyon
2/9/2017 07:05:42 am
I agree with Anthony because the boy wanted all that stuff.
Reply
mejdi
2/9/2017 09:10:42 am
I like your reasons K.B
Reply
anthony
2/9/2017 06:57:30 am
I think the tree is weak for many reasons one reasons is the tree lots his bade parts to the boy to live a life. in the text it says other reasons is that the tree give the boy all his thing to save the boy. the text says that the tree give apps to the boy to sell for the. am sorry boy but I give u all my thing.
Reply
tellyon
2/9/2017 07:02:48 am
The tree is weak. one reason is the tree was giving the boy her apples so the boy can have money. another reason is when the boy came back the boy wanted a house so the boy cut off her branches and made a house and the tree was happy. my final reason is when the boy came back the boy wanted a boat so the boy cut off her stump and made a boat.
Reply
zamal
2/9/2017 07:09:18 am
In my opinion the tree is weak for many reasons. One reason is the tree think he is weak. In the text it says i wish that i could give you something but i have nothing left.Another reason is he have just a stump. In the text it says I am just an old stump. These are some of the reasons why the tree is weak.
Reply
chantel perez
2/9/2017 07:13:34 am
it importan to help the amazon one rosnos is.castello has help care for fish in the amazon.minig can change the water and even.severa things are causing trouble .
Reply
myriq millhouse
2/9/2017 07:20:00 am
i think the tree is weak for many resoans.one resoan is beause the boy cut dwon the brachs i know this b
Reply
shahiem morris
2/9/2017 09:03:29 am
I think that the tree is week for many reasons.
Reply
Jayden
2/9/2017 09:04:36 am
I think the tree stong for many reasons.One reason is she gave all she had for the boy.Another reason is she is letting the boy use her to get what he wants.I know this because in the text it says and the tree was happy but not really
Reply
shahiem morris
2/9/2017 09:08:30 am
Where is all your evidence at in the text Jaden.
Reply
Phil
2/9/2017 09:11:44 am
i agree that the tree is strong Jayden.......;;=====
Reply
mejdi
2/9/2017 09:08:19 am
I think that the tree is weak AND many reason strong for many reasons.One reason is that in the begin the tree had every thing like branch,trunk and leaves.I know this because in the text it says that"every day the boy would come and gather her leaves.Another reason is that the tree is weak and strong because the tree gave every thing to the boy.I know this because in the text it says that"I have nothing to give you.These are my reasons why the tree is weak AND strong
Reply
nick
2/9/2017 09:08:52 am
i disagree with tellyon
Reply
MARQUES CANNON
2/9/2017 09:09:27 am
I think that the tree is weak for many reasons.One reason is becuase it gave the little boy all of her apples.Another reason is because the tree gave the little boy all of her wood.The last reason is because she gave the little boy her intire life so he can get money,get a wife and have children and by a house
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorHey, I'm Miss Griffin. I'm so excited to have you this year. I love reading! My dream is to get each and everyone of you to love it as much as I do. Archives
February 2018
Categories |